Sun bullied, used threats to gain control of open source project, former owner says

By John Fontana, Network World, 11/29/07

 Start a discussion    Print article

 Comments (1)    Print article

Sun used strong-arm tactics and made threats to the owners of an open-source directory project to wrestle away control, according to one of the former owners and creators of the project.

In the process, Sun potentially has torn a gaping hole in the OpenDS (directory service) project, which is creating a free Java-based directory service for large deployments that offers high performance, extensibility and management.

Neil Wilson, who was the co-founder, co-owner and committer of OpenDS and a Sun employee before he was laid off in September, said on his blog and in an interview with Network World, that Sun threatened to terminate his severance benefits and those of three other recently laid-off employees and co-owners of OpenDS if the foursome didn’t amend the OpenDS bylaws to cede control to Sun.

Sun did not respond to requests for comments by the time this story was posted.

“Owners” of open source projects establish the work’s governance and its goals, guide the community effort and resolve disputes among project contributors, among other activities.

The OpenDS bylaws state that governance changes can only be made by a consensus of the project owners, which is standard language for project bylaws, and Wilson says Sun forced him and the others to give up ownership so the vendor could control who was spearheading OpenDS.

“I don’t think at the time they did it [layoffs] that they realized they had laid off the entire ownership of the project. I think they did not know how to handle that,” Wilson said.

On Nov. 14, Wilson said, a Sun executive demanded during a call with one of the four OpenDS co-owners that the owners approve a governance change that would grant Sun full control of the OpenDS project. It was during that call that the co-owner was threatened with the loss of their severance benefits, Wilson said. The threat was not made directly to Wilson, but was directed at all four co-owners, he said.

“This was a very disappointing and hurtful turn of events. I believe that we acted only in good faith and in the best interests of the community,” Wilson wrote on his blog.

Featured Whitepapers

About Us | Contact Us | Advertising Info | Terms of Service/Privacy

Copyright, 2006-2007 Network World, Inc. All rights reserved.